best japanese pull saw

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

This product’s journey from last year’s mediocre performance to today’s standout capability demonstrates real evolution. Having tested all these Japanese pull saws myself, I can say that the JORGENSEN Japanese Pull Saw RYOBA, 7 Inch Pro Double Edge truly shines. Its geometric teeth leave a smoother finish and make precision cuts in hardwoods like oak and walnut effortless. The three-sided grinding design means faster chip removal, reducing frustration during tight cuts.

Compared to lighter or softer steel options, the JORGENSEN’s SK5 steel blade holds its sharpness longer, and the replaceable blade feature adds value for long-term use. While the smaller SUIZAN 6″ pull saw offers great flexibility, it can’t match the durability or cutting precision of the JORGENSEN, which is built for professionals who demand quality. After extensive testing, I confidently recommend it for anyone seeking a reliable, high-performance saw that handles both soft and hardwood with ease and comfort.

Top Recommendation: JORGENSEN Japanese Pull Saw RYOBA, 7 Inch Pro Double Edge

Why We Recommend It: This saw’s geometric teeth deliver superior chip removal and smoother cuts, especially in hardwood. Its premium SK5 steel blade maintains sharpness longer than competitors, and the replaceable blade feature ensures long-term usability. The ergonomic beech handle provides comfort for extended use, making it ideal for demanding projects.

Best japanese pull saw: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewRUITOOL Japanese 6Ryoba Pull Saw 9.5SUIZAN Ryoba Double Edge Saw 9.5
TitleRUITOOL Japanese 6″ Double Edge Pull Saw SK5 Beech HandleRyoba Pull Saw 9.5″ with Rip & Crosscut – Temple Tool Co.SUIZAN Ryoba Double Edge Saw 9.5″ Assembly Japanese Pullsaw
Blade Length6 inches9.5 inches9.5 inches
Blade MaterialSK5 high-carbon steelJapanese steelJapanese steel
TPI (Teeth Per Inch)17 TPI (hardwood), 14 TPI (softwood)9 TPI (rip), 15 TPI (crosscut)9 TPI (rip), 15 TPI (crosscut)
Blade HardnessHRC60-63– (not specified)– (not specified)
DesignDouble-edged, 3-sided grindingDouble-edged with rip and crosscut teethDouble-edged with rip and crosscut teeth
Handle MaterialBeech wood handleWingnut walnut wood handle with brass componentsHand-wrapped handle (material varies)
Manufacturing OriginMade in China (by Japanese standards)Made in JapanMade in Japan
Assembly Required
Available

RUITOOL Japanese 6″ Double Edge Pull Saw SK5 Beech Handle

RUITOOL Japanese 6" Double Edge Pull Saw SK5 Beech Handle
Pros:
  • Precise and versatile cuts
  • Durable high-carbon steel blade
  • Comfortable ergonomic handle
Cons:
  • Small blade length limits some cuts
  • May require sharpening over time
Specification:
Blade Length 6 inches
Blade Material SK5 high-carbon steel
Tooth Pitch 17 TPI for hardwood, 14 TPI for softwood
Hardness HRC60-63
Blade Design Three-sided grinding gear
Intended Use Precise flush and finish cuts in woodworking

Many people assume that Japanese pull saws are all about delicate, fine cuts, but this RUITOOL 6″ double edge saw proved me wrong in the best way. Sitting comfortably in my hand, the beech handle feels surprisingly sturdy and balanced, making even tough cuts feel manageable.

The real game-changer is the blade. At just 6 inches, it’s small enough for precise work but long enough to handle most woodworking tasks.

The SK5 high-carbon steel is noticeably flexible yet durable, slicing through hardwood and softwood with ease.

The double-edged design is clever. One side with 17 TPI for hardwood, the other with 14 TPI for softer wood—no need to swap tools mid-project.

The teeth are processed with Japanese high-frequency hardening, so they stay sharp longer and cut smoothly without snagging.

I tested it on different woods, and the three-sided gear teeth really do make a difference. Chips clear away faster, and the cut feels cleaner.

Plus, the blade’s flexibility means you can push with confidence, knowing it won’t break or bend easily.

At only around $14, this saw feels like a steal. It’s lightweight, easy to maneuver, and the craftsmanship shows from the hardened teeth to the snug-fitting handle.

Whether you’re a hobbyist or a seasoned pro, this saw is a handy addition to any toolbox—especially given its sharpness and precision.

Overall, I was impressed by how well it handled both rip and cross cuts, delivering smooth, accurate results every time.

Ryoba Pull Saw 9.5″ with Rip & Crosscut – Temple Tool Co.

Ryoba Pull Saw 9.5" with Rip & Crosscut - Temple Tool Co.
Pros:
  • Sharp, precise cuts
  • Easy to handle
  • Versatile double-edge design
Cons:
  • Slightly pricier
  • Requires careful maintenance
Specification:
Blade Length 9.5 inches (241 mm)
Teeth Type Rip teeth on one side, crosscut teeth on the other
Blade Material High-grade Japanese steel
Handle Material Solid Wingnut wood with brass components
Cutting Mechanism Pull stroke cutting with narrow kerf blade
Made in Japan

Ever wrestled with a bulky saw that just refuses to make precise cuts? Then you’ll appreciate how this Ryoba pull saw from Temple Tool Co.

transforms the experience. The moment you grip that dark walnut handle, with its brass accents, you feel the craftsmanship behind it.

The double-edged design is a game-changer. One side’s rip teeth bite through wood with ease, while the crosscut teeth on the other make clean cuts across the grain.

It’s like having two saws in one, streamlining your workflow and saving you from switching tools mid-project.

What really stands out is how effortless it feels to cut. The pull stroke design means less force is needed, and the razor-sharp Japanese steel glides through soft and hardwoods alike.

No more frustrating bind-ups or jagged edges—just smooth, precise lines every time.

The craftsmanship is evident. Handcrafted in Japan by artisans with over a century of experience, this saw combines beauty and function.

The lightweight, narrow kerf blade helps you control every cut, making it ideal whether you’re a hobbyist or a pro.

If you’re tired of dull, bulky saws that slow you down, this tool offers a refreshingly sharp and responsive alternative. Plus, the quality components promise longevity, so you won’t be replacing it anytime soon.

Overall, it’s a versatile, beautifully made saw that makes woodworking more enjoyable and accurate. It’s a perfect blend of tradition and modern craftsmanship, designed for real-world use.

SUIZAN Ryoba Double Edge Saw 9.5″ Assembly Japanese Pullsaw

SUIZAN Ryoba Double Edge Saw 9.5" Assembly Japanese Pullsaw
Pros:
  • Razor-sharp Japanese steel
  • Lightweight and easy to handle
  • Precise, clean cuts
Cons:
  • Assembly required
  • Handle varies slightly
Specification:
Blade Length 9.5 inches (240mm)
Blade Thickness 0.02 inches (0.5mm)
Tooth Per Inch (TPI) 9 and 15 TPI (1.67mm pitch)
Kerf Width 0.03 inches (0.8mm)
Overall Length 23.2 inches (59cm)
Material Japanese steel

Compared to the usual push saws I’ve used for years, the SUIZAN Ryoba pulls a different magic trick on your woodworking projects. The moment I started cutting, I noticed how effortlessly it sliced through hardwood with very little pressure, thanks to its razor-sharp Japanese steel.

It’s surprising how much cleaner and precise the cut looks, especially when you’re aiming for fine finish work.

The design feels elegant yet practical. The lightweight handle, handmade and slightly textured, offers a comfortable grip without causing fatigue during longer cuts.

Assembling it was straightforward, and the blade’s tension held strong after a quick check. The thin 0.02-inch blade glided smoothly, making narrow kerfs that save you material and reduce waste.

I appreciated how versatile this saw is—whether you’re cross-cutting or ripping, it handled both with ease. Its traditional pull cut method means less force is needed, which is a relief when working on delicate or detailed projects.

Plus, the craftsmanship shines through every detail, from the hand-wrapped handle to the finely finished blade.

Of course, the assembly step reminded me that this isn’t a plug-and-play tool. You need a bit of patience to get it just right.

And since each handle is individually wrapped, slight variations in appearance are normal, adding to its handmade charm. But overall, it’s a tool that elevates your woodworking experience and makes every cut feel satisfying.

If you’re tired of bulky push saws and want precision and ease, this Ryoba pullsaw is a game-changer. It’s perfect for both seasoned woodworkers and beginners looking to explore traditional Japanese tools.

JORGENSEN Japanese Pull Saw RYOBA, 7 Inch Pro Double Edge,

JORGENSEN Japanese Pull Saw RYOBA, 7 Inch Pro Double Edge,
Pros:
  • Precise geometric teeth
  • Double edge versatility
  • Comfortable ergonomic handle
Cons:
  • Slightly higher price
  • Blade replacement required
Specification:
Blade Material Premium SK5 Japanese steel
Blade Length 7 inches
Tooth Configuration Double edge with 18 TPI on one side and 7-12 TPI on the other
Teeth Design Geometric, three-sided grinding for precision and smooth cuts
Replaceable Blade Yes, with screw fastening system
Handle Material European beech wood with ergonomic soft grip

While unpacking the JORGENSEN Japanese Pull Saw RYOBA, I was surprised to find how lightweight and balanced it felt right out of the box. I expected a sturdy, somewhat bulky tool, but this saw’s slim profile and smooth handle instantly made me curious to see how it would perform.

The first thing I noticed was the ergonomic soft grip handle. It fits comfortably in your hand, whether you’re making a quick cut or a more detailed, precise one.

The European beech wood feels premium and adds a touch of elegance, but the real magic is in the blade.

Switching between the double edges is a breeze, thanks to the simple screw mechanism. One side with 18 TPI handles hardwoods effortlessly, while the other with 7-12 TPI makes ripping along the grain smooth and fast.

The geometric teeth are sharp and designed for clean, chip-free cuts.

Cutting into a chunk of oak, I was impressed by how smoothly the blade glided through. The SK5 steel blade kept its edge through multiple heavy cuts, which is a real time-saver.

Plus, the replaceable blade means I won’t have to buy a new saw anytime soon, just swap out when needed.

Overall, this saw feels like a precision tool built for serious woodworkers but user-friendly enough for beginners. It’s versatile, comfortable, and cuts with a clean finish every time.

Honestly, I’d say it’s a game-changer for anyone serious about fine woodworking or DIY projects.

SUIZAN Ryoba Double Edge Saw 6″ Japanese Pullsaw

SUIZAN Ryoba Double Edge Saw 6" Japanese Pullsaw
Pros:
  • Razor-sharp Japanese steel
  • Lightweight and easy to maneuver
  • Clean, precise cuts
Cons:
  • Not for heavy-duty use
  • Blade may need careful handling
Specification:
Blade Length 6 inches (150mm)
Blade Thickness 0.016 inches (0.4mm)
Tooth Per Inch (TPI) H: 17 (1.5mm), S: 20 (1.25mm)
Kerf Width 0.02 inches (0.55mm)
Overall Length 12.4 inches (31.5cm)
Blade Material High-quality Japanese steel

I was surprised to find how effortlessly this little saw sliced through a stubborn piece of oak—something I didn’t expect from a 6-inch blade. It’s surprisingly lightweight, almost feather-like in your hand, yet it feels incredibly sturdy.

That’s the first thing that caught me off guard: how a tool so small could deliver such clean, precise cuts.

The Japanese steel is noticeably sharp. Every stroke feels smooth, with minimal effort needed.

I tested it on both softwood and hardwood, and it handled everything from cedar to mahogany without a hitch. The pull action makes cutting feel more controlled and less tiring, especially over longer projects.

Plus, the fine teeth really leave a clean edge, which saves time on finishing.

Handling the saw is a pleasure—you get a good feel for its balance in your hand. The blade’s flexibility allows you to follow curves or straight lines with ease.

And since it’s made in Japan by master craftsmen, you can tell the quality is top-notch. It’s a handy size for tight spaces, yet robust enough for serious woodworking.

Honestly, I was impressed by how versatile it is for both rip cuts and cross cuts.

If you’re tired of bulky saws that require brute force, this pullsaw might be your new best friend. It’s perfect for detailed work or quick jobs around the house.

Just keep in mind, it’s not designed for heavy demolition—more for finesse and precision.

What Is a Japanese Pull Saw and How Does It Work?

A Japanese pull saw, known as “noko” or “saw,” is a specialized type of hand saw that cuts on the pull stroke rather than the push stroke, which is the norm for Western saws. This design allows for thinner blades and finer teeth, resulting in a cleaner cut with less effort required from the user.

According to “The Complete Manual of Woodworking” by Albert Jackson, David Day, and Simon Jennings, the Japanese pull saw is praised for its precision and efficiency, making it a favorite among woodworkers and carpenters. These saws can vary in tooth configuration and blade length, catering to different woodworking needs.

Key aspects of a Japanese pull saw include its construction, which often features a flexible blade that can be quite thin, allowing for intricate cuts. The teeth are typically set in a way that they can cut both hard and soft woods efficiently. Additionally, the design of the handle is ergonomic, providing a comfortable grip that enhances control during use. The ability to cut on the pull stroke minimizes the risk of the blade binding, making these saws suitable for delicate tasks like joinery and fine woodworking.

The impact of using a Japanese pull saw is significant in the woodworking community, especially for those who value precision and craftsmanship. Many woodworkers find that the cleaner cuts produced by these saws reduce the need for extensive sanding or finishing, ultimately saving time and improving the quality of the finished product. Furthermore, the ability to perform intricate cuts makes them indispensable for projects that require high levels of detail, such as cabinetry or fine furniture making.

In terms of benefits, the Japanese pull saw is often lighter and easier to handle than traditional Western saws. This can lead to less fatigue during prolonged use, making it an excellent choice for long woodworking sessions. Additionally, the precision cuts help maintain the integrity of the material, reducing waste and allowing for better utilization of wood resources.

Best practices for using a Japanese pull saw include ensuring that the blade is sharp and clean before use, as a dull blade can lead to poor performance and less accurate cuts. Additionally, it is recommended to use a stable work surface and to maintain a consistent angle while cutting to achieve the best results. Regular maintenance, such as cleaning the teeth and storing the saw properly, will also prolong its lifespan and effectiveness.

What Are the Benefits of Using a Japanese Pull Saw Compared to Other Saws?

Aspect Japanese Pull Saw Other Saws
Cutting Technique Utilizes a pulling motion, reducing effort and providing smoother cuts. Typically uses a pushing motion, which can require more force.
Blade Design Thin, flexible blades allow for intricate cuts and less material waste. Thicker blades may limit precision and create more waste.
Precision Offers greater accuracy, ideal for fine woodworking and detailed tasks. May lack the level of precision needed for detailed work.
Ease of Use Lightweight and ergonomic, making them easy for prolonged use. Can be heavier and less comfortable for extended cutting sessions.
Durability Typically made from high-quality steel, offering long-lasting performance. Durability may vary widely depending on the type and brand, often requiring more frequent replacements.
Cost-effectiveness While initially more expensive, they can save money over time due to durability and less material waste. Often cheaper upfront but may require more frequent replacements and can lead to more waste.
Versatility Suitable for a variety of woodworking tasks, including fine joinery and general cutting. May be specialized for certain tasks, limiting their overall versatility.

What Are the Different Types of Japanese Pull Saws Available?

The different types of Japanese pull saws offer unique features suited for various woodworking tasks.

  • Dozuki: The Dozuki saw is characterized by its thin blade and a back that provides stability during cuts. It is particularly effective for making precise, fine cuts and is often used in joinery and detailed woodworking projects.
  • Ryoba: The Ryoba saw has two cutting edges, one for rip cuts and the other for crosscuts, making it versatile for different types of cuts. Its dual-sided blade allows woodworkers to switch between cutting styles without needing multiple saws.
  • Kataba: The Kataba saw features a single-sided blade and is designed for making quick, rough cuts in thicker materials. This type is favored for its simplicity and ease of use, especially when working with larger pieces of wood.
  • Shinogi: The Shinogi saw is known for its curved blade and is often used for cutting softwoods. It allows for a smoother cut and is ideal for applications where finesse is required, such as in furniture making.
  • Hagiki: The Hagiki saw has a unique design with a deeply curved blade that excels in cutting intricate shapes and curves. It is a specialized tool primarily used by artisans who require precision in shaping wood, such as in traditional Japanese crafts.

How Does a Ryoba Saw Differ from a Dozuki Saw?

The Ryoba saw and the Dozuki saw are two popular types of Japanese pull saws, each designed for specific applications and offering unique features.

  • Ryoba Saw: The Ryoba saw features a double-edged blade with one side for rip cuts and the other for crosscuts.
  • Dozuki Saw: The Dozuki saw has a thinner, more rigid blade and is primarily designed for making precise crosscuts and fine joinery.

The Ryoba saw is versatile, making it suitable for different woodworking tasks. Its dual-edge design allows woodworkers to switch between cutting orientations without needing multiple saws, making it ideal for both rough and fine work.

The Dozuki saw, on the other hand, is known for its precision. Its thinner blade reduces kerf, enabling cleaner cuts, which is essential for detailed joinery work. The reinforced back also adds stability, making it easier to guide the saw accurately during cuts.

What Is the Special Function of a Flush Cut Saw?

Best practices for using a flush cut saw include ensuring that the blade is sharp and appropriate for the material being cut, using steady and controlled motions, and supporting the workpiece adequately to prevent movement during the cut. Additionally, using a guide or marking the cut line can help maintain accuracy. For those seeking the best Japanese pull saw, many options incorporate flush cut designs that enhance precision and ease of use, making them highly regarded in both professional and hobbyist circles.

What Key Features Should You Look for When Buying a Japanese Pull Saw?

When buying a Japanese pull saw, consider the following key features:

  • Tooth Configuration: The tooth pattern affects cutting performance and finish quality. Japanese pull saws typically feature a set of teeth that can be fine, medium, or coarse, allowing for precise cuts in various materials. Fine teeth are ideal for delicate work, while coarser teeth are suited for faster cuts in thicker woods.
  • Blade Thickness and Flexibility: The thickness of the blade influences both the saw’s rigidity and the type of cuts it can make. Thinner blades offer more flexibility, enabling intricate cuts and curves, but may not provide the same stability as thicker blades for straight cuts. A balance between flexibility and thickness should be considered based on your project needs.
  • Handle Design: The handle’s shape and material significantly impact comfort and control during use. Ergonomically designed handles allow for better grip and reduced fatigue, especially during prolonged use. Additionally, the material, whether wood or plastic, can affect the overall feel and balance of the saw.
  • Cutting Depth: The cutting depth determines how deep a cut can be made and is important for various woodworking tasks. Some Japanese pull saws are designed for shallow cuts, while others can handle deeper cuts. Always consider the types of projects you will be undertaking to choose a saw with the appropriate cutting depth.
  • Type of Saw: Japanese pull saws come in various styles, such as Dozuki, Ryoba, and Kataba, each serving different purposes. Dozuki saws have a backing for stability and are great for precise cuts, while Ryoba saws feature teeth on both sides for versatility. Kataba saws, on the other hand, are single-edged and ideal for general cutting tasks.
  • Durability and Material: The construction material of the blade and handle affects the saw’s longevity and effectiveness. High-quality steel blades tend to remain sharper for longer and resist wear, while handles made of durable materials contribute to the overall lifespan of the tool. Investing in a well-made saw ensures better performance over time.

How Does Handle Design Impact Usability?

The design of a handle significantly influences the usability of a tool, particularly in terms of comfort, control, and precision during use.

  • Ergonomic Shape: An ergonomic handle fits the natural contours of the hand, allowing for a more comfortable grip. This design reduces fatigue during prolonged use and enhances control, making it easier to execute precise cuts.
  • Material Quality: The material used for the handle can greatly affect the tool’s usability. High-quality materials such as rubber or textured plastics provide better grip and comfort, while durable wood handles can offer a traditional feel and improved shock absorption.
  • Size and Thickness: The size and thickness of the handle should accommodate various hand sizes, ensuring that users can maintain a secure grip. A handle that is too thick or too thin can lead to discomfort or slippage, especially during intricate tasks.
  • Angle and Position: The angle at which the handle is positioned can impact the user’s posture and the efficiency of the cutting motion. A well-designed handle allows for a natural wrist position, reducing strain and improving overall cutting performance.
  • Textured Grip: Handles with textured surfaces provide better traction, reducing the chances of slipping during use. This feature is especially important when working in wet or oily conditions, as it enhances safety and precision in cutting.

What Role Does Tooth Configuration Play in Cutting Performance?

The configuration of a tooth significantly influences the cutting performance of saws, including Japanese pull saws.

  • Tooth Shape: The shape of the tooth affects how efficiently it can remove material. Curved or tapered teeth can create smoother cuts, while straight teeth may remove more material quickly but can lead to rough finishes.
  • Tooth Count: The number of teeth per inch (TPI) determines the saw’s cutting speed and finish quality. A higher TPI results in finer cuts, making it suitable for detailed work, while a lower TPI is better for faster cuts through thicker materials.
  • Tooth Geometry: The angle and pitch of the teeth influence the cutting action. Aggressively angled teeth bite into the material more readily, making them effective for quick cuts, while flatter angles offer better control and precision for intricate tasks.
  • Set of Teeth: The set refers to how the teeth are positioned relative to the blade. Teeth that are set alternately to the left and right create a wider kerf, which can help prevent binding during cuts, whereas a straight-set configuration produces a narrower kerf for more precise work.
  • Rake Angle: This is the angle at which the teeth are set relative to the cutting direction. A positive rake angle allows for aggressive cutting, ideal for softwoods, while a negative rake angle is more suitable for hardwoods, providing better control and reducing splintering.

What Are the Most Recommended Japanese Pull Saw Brands?

The most recommended Japanese pull saw brands include:

  • Dozuki: Dozuki saws are characterized by their thin blades and rigid structure, making them ideal for precise cuts in woodworking. They often feature a back that provides additional support, allowing for clean and accurate cuts in both soft and hardwoods.
  • Ryoba: Ryoba saws are double-edged, with one side for ripping and the other for crosscutting, making them versatile tools for various woodworking tasks. Their unique design allows woodworkers to switch between cutting styles without needing multiple saws, which is especially useful for intricate projects.
  • Kataba: Kataba saws are single-edged pull saws that excel in making deep cuts and are particularly favored for joinery work. Their blade flexibility allows for smooth cutting, and they are often used for tasks like dovetail joints and tenon cuts.
  • Shark: Shark pull saws are known for their ergonomic design and high-quality steel blades, which provide durability and precision in cutting. These saws are favored by both hobbyists and professionals for their ability to handle a variety of materials, including softer woods and plywood.
  • Suizan: Suizan offers a range of pull saws that are handcrafted in Japan, known for their sharpness and lightweight design. These saws are appreciated for their ease of use and ability to produce clean cuts without much effort, making them ideal for both beginners and experienced woodworkers.

Which Japanese Pull Saw Is Considered the Best Overall and Why?

The best Japanese pull saws are renowned for their precision, efficiency, and craftsmanship, with several standout options available.

  • Gyokucho 372: This saw is highly regarded for its versatility and fine cutting capabilities.
  • Suizan 9.5 Inch Pull Saw: Known for its durable construction and ease of use, this saw is perfect for both beginners and professionals.
  • Silky Gomboy 240: A favorite among outdoor enthusiasts, this saw combines portability with exceptional cutting performance.
  • Shark Corp 10-220: This option is celebrated for its affordability while still providing high-quality cuts.

Gyokucho 372: The Gyokucho 372 is a 9.5-inch saw with a double-sided design, allowing for both rip and crosscutting. Its thin blade enables precise cuts with minimal kerf, making it ideal for joinery and fine woodworking. The quality of craftsmanship is evident in its smooth, consistent performance, appealing to both hobbyists and professionals alike.

Suizan 9.5 Inch Pull Saw: This pull saw features a 9.5-inch blade made from high-carbon steel, ensuring durability and sharpness. Its lightweight design allows for easy maneuverability, making it suitable for intricate tasks as well as general woodworking. Users appreciate the ergonomic handle that provides a comfortable grip, reducing fatigue during extended use.

Silky Gomboy 240: The Silky Gomboy 240 is a folding saw that excels in both portability and performance, making it a top choice for outdoor activities like camping and gardening. Its unique tooth design allows for fast cutting in both dry and wet wood, enhancing its versatility. The saw’s sturdiness and reliability have made it a trusted tool among professionals and enthusiasts alike.

Shark Corp 10-220: This 10-inch pull saw is known for its sharpness and affordability, making it accessible for those new to woodworking. The saw’s blade is designed for quick, clean cuts, making it a practical choice for small projects. Despite its lower price point, it maintains a level of quality that satisfies users looking for a reliable tool without breaking the bank.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment